Back door Roth residual earnings

Submitted by Denny Pierre on Thu, 2017-04-20 22:01

Prior to the tax filing deadline a person makes a 2015 non deductible contribution to a Traditional IRA of $5,500 (contributor was 49 in 2015) with the intention of executing a ‘back door Roth’. Before the conversion to the Roth takes place $0.10 interest is earned and posted to the account, then a partial conversion of $5,500 is executed, thereby leaving $0.10 in the Traditional IRA. After the conversion takes place an additional $0.56 of interest earned prior to the conversion is posted to the acct after the conversion, now leaving $0.66 in the Traditional IRA. This $0.66 was not noticed until 4/18/2017. Then on 4/18/2017 another non deductible contribution is made to a Traditional IRA for 2016 of $6,500 (contributor was 50 in 2016) with the intention of converting this via ‘back door Roth’ strategy. What can should be done to the $0.66?



Submitted by Alan - IRA critic on Thu, 2017-04-20 22:49

  • Whenever a back door Roth conversion is done, these incidental earnings amounts should be converted. In this case, the 8606 reporting the conversion might be off by a dollar once the year end balance left in the TIRA reached .50 since that rounds up to a dollar. The 8606 should report a dollar on line 6 as the year end balance in the TIRA and that would cause the conversion to have a taxable amount of one dollar. These differences are so small that I would not bother to amend the 1040 for such a difference.
  • Having a small balance left in the IRA after converting might prevent the custodian from closing the account, so there would still be a TIRA open for the next contribution.
  • In other words, having a small amount of earnings left after conversion has no real tax impact other than triggering a couple more lines on the 8606, and annoying the TP by being there. Typically, whenever the TP converts, the entire TIRA balance should be converted if it is small.

Add new comment

Log in or register to post comments

Sign up to receive The Slott Report each week