Estate question regarding IRA that had beneficiaries listed, but they were deceased.

My elder cousin had an IRA with three segments.
He lived in Washington State when he died. He worked in Minnesota up until he retired and his IRA is held in a company there. He was never married and never had children.
Two of the IRA parts had beneficiaries (his parents) who were deceased. Beneficiary designation was not updated before my cousin died. The third piece of the IRA had a living beneficiary and was dispersed to that person as a lump sum.

The executor of the estate asked the company who holds the IRA if the remaining two parts of the IRA could be carved up into inherited IRAs for the three people who are beneficiaries listed in the Will. They answered no. They stated that since the beneficiaries of the remaining IRA pieces are deceased, the IRA must go to the estate.
The two options given to the executor:

1. Cash out the IRA and take a tax hit, put the funds into the estate.
2. Leave the IRA at the company holding it and take annual RMD, then split the RMD among the three beneficiaries in the Will accordingly.

My question: Can the executor ask that the IRA be transferred to the estate as an inherited IRA for the estate of…and then when the estate is closed, could the inherited IRA be split up to separate IRAs for the beneficiaries of the estate?

Or- Could the executor file a PLR with the IRS requesting that permission be granted to require the company holding the IRA to carve up the IRA into inherited IRAs for the beneficiaries listed in the Will?
Thank you for your advice.



  • The executor of his estate can assign the inherited IRA to the beneficiaries under the will, and this IRA custodian should know that. However, some IRA custodians, particularly banks, do not really want to create mutliple inherited IRAs and would rather push out a lump sum to the estate that destroys any stretch. The executor should push back and resist any such lump sum distribution. A PLR is not necessary and would be very expensive.
  • The executor needs to submit a death certificate and have the IRA re titled to the estate, but should not even supply the EIN to the IRA custodian unless they agree to accept assignment to the beneficiaries.
  • The living beneficiary’s lump sum distribution will take care of any uncompleted year of death RMD of the decedent.
  • See Natalie Choate’s article below:
  • https://www.ataxplan.com/bulletin-board/notice-to-executors-and-trustees/

Thank you very much for the advice, I appreciate it.

Add new comment

Log in or register to post comments