Treatment of Fractional Shares for NUA
Earlier this month my wife completed a lump-sum distribution from a former employer’s retirement plan administered by Fidelity Investments, where my wife has had a Roth IRA for many years. My wife’s assets in the plan included a large amount of company stock, and she wanted to take advantage of the favorable tax treatment given to the NUA (her cost basis in the stock was approximately 27% of its fair market value). She asked the Fidelity representative who handled the distribution to distribute the company stock to a Fidelity taxable brokerage account and the non-stock assets to a Fidelity rollover IRA. The Fidelity representative advised that only whole shares of the company stock would be distributed to the brokerage account and that the remaining fractional share would be paid in cash. My wife has received a check from the plan representing the fractional share, but she has not yet cashed it. I want to verify that the plan’s payment of the fractional share in cash does not impair the favorable tax treatment given to the NUA of the whole shares. I appreciate any feedback you can provide.
Permalink Submitted by Alan - IRA critic on Sun, 2018-11-25 21:33
The distribution is not a problem with respect to using NUA since the fractional share value is just part of the lump sum distribution required to qualify for NUA. However, am not sure if the 1099R reporting the share distribution will also include the fractional share value but without the Box 2a cost basis and Box 6 NUA value included for just that fractional share. The plan might also separate this into two different 1099R forms, but either way should not change the amount of cost basis or NUA reported on the whole shares. There is no reason that the proceeds paid in cash could not be rolled over within 60 days to the rollover IRA as long as she is sure that the cash proceeds were not included in the cost basis and NUA amounts on the 1099R. In other words, it is not totally clear how the plan is going to report this cash distribution and therefore how it will be reported on your tax return. You could either wait for the 1099R forms or call the plan to find out how they intend to report the cash distribution if you want to know sooner.