Excess Roth contribution for 2020

Taxpayer is single with 2020 AGI in excess of amount allowable for a Roth IRA contribution. He is not a participant in an employer plan. His 2020 return reflects a $6,000 TIRA contribution deduction and has not yet been filed (due May 15th). When he reviewed his records last week prior to making the TIRA contribution, he discovered that he had already made a $6,000 Roth contribution for 2020 in July 2020, adding to an existing Roth IRA (into which he had made a contribution for at least tax year 2019). Apparently, in July 2020 he had made $6,000 Roth contributions for both 2019 and 2020 (not anticipating his income for 2020 could be over the allowable limit). The $6,000 for 2019 was an allowable contribution.

The contributed funds went into to a money market account earning virtually nothing so far. His 2020 AGI was expected to be below the Roth AGI limitation level, but that assumption turned out to be incorrect in retrospect. What is the easiest way to correct this?

1 Ask the custodian to recharacterize the July 2020 Roth contribution to a TIRA. The earnings would be minimal I expect.
2, What should be done with those earnings?
3. Any Form 8606 implication to his 2020 or 2021 returns?
4. Should a statement be attached to his 2020 return explaining what transpired?

Alan, as always, thank you for your help.



He never made the 2020 TIRA contribution, but his return shows a TIRA contribution?  Does he want the TIRA deduction?

Yes, he does.  When he went to make his 2020 TIRA contribution last week, he discovered that he had already made a contribution for 2020 last July, but had made it as a Roth contribution.   How best to fix this?

If he did NOT make the recent TIRA contribution, and only has the 2020 Roth contribution, he should recharcterize the 2020 Roth contribution as a TIRA contribution, and the 2020 return already shows a deducted TIRA contribution so that return is fine as is. The earnings on the Roth contribution also transfer to the TIRA as a tax free transfer, so the end result is that his 2020 contribution will be treated as if it were a TIRA contribution all along.
Since the 2020 return is already filed without an explanatory statement, there won’t be one since it is not worth the hassle to file an amended return just to include the statement. In the unlikely event he gets an IRS inquiry about a Roth excess, he can respond to that at the time. But the IRS usually waits until any 1099R forms (recharacterization 1099R) are issued for the following year before contacting taxpayers since recharacterizations or removal of excesses are so commonplace. The IRS can figure out what was done from the 1099R issued next January.
Form 8606 does not apply since the 2020 recharacterized TIRA contribution has been deducted.

Add new comment

Log in or register to post comments