Which Old Retirement Plan Records Can Be Safely Shredded Now?

1. Which of the below-listed 4 kinds of retirement plan financial and administrative records should be retained for a possible future IRS inquiry and which can be safely shredded now?

2. Once the retirement plan owners are deceased and their IRA plans’ assets have been
inherited by their beneficiaries, can all these records be safely shredded or which need to be retained by their beneficiaries?

3. Similarly, which of the plan owners’ income tax returns from 1987 on can be shredded now and which need to be retained after their deaths?

a. An M.D. employer adopted a prototype Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) effective 1/1/88 to cover himself and his 1 employee who was also his wife. On 12/7/93 the DBP assets were directly rolled over to a Vanguard money purchase pension plan (MPPP) into an account for the employer and into an account for the employee. The employer retired in 1994. On 1/19/99 the assets in the employee’s MPPP were directly rolled over to her Vanguard TIRA and on 2/4/02 the assets in the employer’s MPPP were directly rolled over to his Vanguard TIRA.

b. The employer and employee had contributed to Keogh profit sharing plans from 1963 through 1987 and again in 1994 when they retired. In 2009 Vanguard closed their Keogh plan and their assets were directly rolled over to their Vanguard TIRA’s.

c. They had also contributed mostly to non-Vanguard TIRA’s from 1982 through 1994 that were later all put in their Vanguard TIRA’s.

d. They Roth converted some of their Vanguard TIRA’s in 1998 and again in 2009 and filed Forms 8606.


Thank you for your help.



  • Of course, there is no way to determine what is 100% safe or even mostly safe. However, the IRS has not had a history of delving back decades into retirement plan issues. No one has ever posted due to an IRS inquiry or audit on an issue more than a couple years back, so I think that dated issues are very rare. Exposure of older accounts is greater if the taxpayer has a history of IRS problems, since many issues are discovered due to an audit initially triggered for other reasons. Therefore, if a taxpayer has had IRS inquiries in the last 10 years, particularly with respect to retirement accounts, I would retain records longer. Same if a taxpayer has personal concerns over what was done and/or if there are any prior disgruntled employees likely to file a complaint. Death of plan owner often further reduces any remaining exposure for the estate.
  • I am not factoring in any specific retention requirements for different types of retirement plan records. Those should be observed.
  • In 1a thru 1d, those records can probably be shredded. They should be sure an TIRA basis is correct per Form 8606 before shredding tax returns after 1986. For the Roth, once it is qualified, the old contribution records can be shredded, at least those prior to 2008.

 



I appreciate your prompt and thoughtful response.  Many thanks for the considerable help you have provided to me and to so many others.  My best wishes for the new year.



Add new comment

Log in or register to post comments