Terminate 401k; Establish SEP IRA

Client is Sub-S Corp w/ 4 employees, 2 of which are husband & wife owning 94% of the business & one employee who owns the other 6%. They hate the paperwork, reporting & the expense of maintaining the plan, including the high fees of the MFs they must select from. They have contacted their 401k administrator to terminate the plan effective 12/15/17 so all liquidated funds for the 4 participants can be mailed to the institutional SEP custodian (likes of a Fidelity, Vanguard, or Folio) to arrive 1st few days of January 2018. That way, the Sub-S only has one QP in 2017 & in 2018.

However, the 401k administrator just made them aware, much to their surprise, that in order to terminate the plan effective 12/15/17, they must do a final Safe Harbor calculation & therefore will send them the plan termination/safe harbor cessation notice by Nov 1 so they you can provide that to the plan participants to sign & return immediately so the administrators can calculate the final safe harbor contribution.

Apparently, this is the 1st time the majority owners ever heard they had a safe harbor plan or that they would have to make a final safe harbor contribution prior to terminating the 401k. Is that really possible to only know of such a safe harbor contribution just prior to terminating a 401k plan? Or, would it have been possible to have a safe harbor plan but never a safe harbor contribution until termination?

Additionally, their past investment advisor told the majority owners if they terminate the 401k in favor of a SEP IRA that SEP IRAs will require distributions to match for all employees! For example, if the 2 majority owners contributed to the SEP IRA $1K per month, the same would need to happen for all vested employees. I have never heard of such a thing. What is that investment advisor inferring? What is behind that comment? Or, assuming you are also surprised by such a statement, tell me the question my client should ask that investment advisor to get to the bottom of this statement?



  • Safe Harbor 401k plans have very specific rules that the plan must follow. You would not be expected to know all of them. That is why you have a professional administrator for the plan. A safe harbor plan is the price for three > 5% owners not to be restricted in their employee deferrals.
  • Safe Harbor 401k plans have specific notification and termination requirements.
  • The past investment advisor was correct. Normally you must give the exact same SEP IRA contribution percentages to every employer.
  • It sounds like your problem may be your administrative costs and fund expense ratios, not necessarily the fact that it is a Safe Harbor 401k Plan.
  • There may be a better solution to your problems. There are lower cost administrators these days that will support low expense ratio index fund plans. Why don’t you investigate that as an option.

See subject above.

Add new comment

Log in or register to post comments