401k After-Tax Contribution Rollover to Roth IRA Problem
Facts:
Client age 60, retired December 2021.
In Jan 2022 with 401k custodian client processed the following rollovers:
1. 3.7M taxable portion of 401k, check to be made payable to client’s TRADITIONAL IRA
2. 20k after-tax contribution portion of 401k, check to be made payable to client’s ROTH IRA
Instead of sending two separate rollover checks, the 401k custodian (one of the largest), the custodian instead sent client 1 rollover check of $3,720,000 made payable to client’s TRADITIONAL IRA.
Client called custodian a few days ago and the custodian admitted a mistake was made and that two separate rollover checks should have been sent.
Today, however, custodian is saying they can send two checks, but the 20k after-tax contribution check must be made payable directly to client and cannot be made payable to his ROTH IRA.
QUESTION:
If the 20k after-tax contribution check is made payable to the client himself and not to his ROTH IRA, can he simply deposit this check into his checking account and make a new check payable to his ROTH IRA and roll it over within 60 days? Any other issues to worry about?
Thanks,
Permalink Submitted by Alan - IRA critic on Tue, 2022-02-01 19:55
Yes, the 20k can be rolled over to the Roth IRA within 60 days of receipt. No other issues to worry about and the one rollover limitation per 12 months does not apply to employer plan distributions. And he will get two 1099R forms since the distribution codes will differ. Separate 1099R forms makes it easier to file with some tax programs.